‘I Did It’ & ‘Amazing Grace’: Jurors in Shayna Hubers Re-Trial Hear Defendant in Her Own Words

Shayna Hubers looks back as her attorneys talk opening statements during her trial at the Campbell County courthouse on Tuesday August 14, 2018.

The first — and so far only — witness to testify in the Shayna Hubers re-trial played a recording of a 911 call Hubers made after shooting and killing her boyfriend, attorney Ryan Poston, in October 2012. That witness, Lt. David Fornash, also played a jailhouse interrogation recording of Hubers.

In the 911 call, a frantic Hubers said she shot Ryan Poston in self-defense. “He threw me across the room,” Hubers told the dispatcher. After firing the initial shots, Hubers waited, then fired additional bullets to administer a coup de grâce.

Defense attorney David Eldridge previously said during opening statements Hubers fired the initial shots when Poston moved his arm toward a gun during an alleged domestic abuse incident. Hubers grabbed the gun first and fired.

The interrogation recording, played later, is best described as a soliloquy of Hubers’ thoughts in the hours after the shooting. At one point, she discussed why she killed Poston. “I was watching him die. It was so painful,” Hubers said in the police interrogation room. “I walked around and shot him where I knew he would die fast.”

At other times, Hubers cried, sang ‘Amazing Grace,’ contemplated who could testify at her trial, and said, “I did it; yes, I did it.” At another point, she told a female officer, “I’m not a murderer, ma’am.”

Yet Hubers also said this in the interrogation room:  “I shot him in the face. I gave him the nose job he wanted.”

Lt. Fornash testified that he responded to the scene when Hubers was arrested. He later returned to the scene to examine the evidence.

Fornash testified that Poston’s condominum, where the shooting occurred was dusty, unkempt, and “a mess.” He chalked that up to the tidiness habits — or lack thereof — of a young man Poston’s age. He examined and showed photos to jurors of a bookcase in the condo. Hubers apparently said she had been knocked or thrown against it. Fornash said he considered it suspicious that nothing was knocked off the shelf in the alleged fight between Poston and Hubers. Some books on the shelf were knocked around however.

Fornash also oversaw the collection of photos of Hubers’ body immediately after the shooting and several days later. A slight discoloration on Hubers’ inner thigh was insignificant, he believed, and another set of marks near the base of Hubers’ thumb were birthmarks, he said, citing a statement from Hubers herself.

Cross-examination of Fornash is expected Wednesday morning.

Hubers is being tried for a second time on charges she murdered Poston. Her defense team discovered that a juror failed to mention a felony record. Since felons are not eligible to serve on Kentucky juries, her original conviction was thrown out and her case is being re-tried.


[Image via Phil Didion/Pool/The Cincinnati Enquirer.]

More Stories About This Trial

Aaron Keller is an attorney licensed in two states. He holds a juris doctor degree from the University of New Hampshire School of Law and a broadcast journalism degree from Syracuse University. During law school, he completed legal residencies in the Office of the New Hampshire Attorney General and in a local prosecutor’s office. He was employed as a summer associate in the New Hampshire Department of Safety, which manages the state police, and further served as a summer law clerk for a New York trial judge. Before law school, Keller worked for television stations in New York and in the Midwest, mostly as an evening news anchor and investigative reporter. His original reporting on the Wisconsin murder of Teresa Halbach was years later featured in the Netflix film "Making A Murderer."

  1. Mediaite
  2. The Mary Sue
  3. RunwayRiot
  4. Law & Crime
  5. AmboTV