Jane Doe 5 Testifies She Wasn’t Able to See What Kellen Winslow Did Under the Water in Jacuzzi Incident

Jane Doe 5 testified Thursday in the sexual misconduct trial of former NFL tight end Kellen Winslow. She detailed two incidents in which the defendant performed lewd acts at her. First, he stroked himself in front of her while she was using an exercise machine at a gym, and second, there was an incident weeks later when he was masturbating at the jacuzzi, she said. During cross-examination, defense lawyer Marc Carlos pressed her on whether she saw what she claimed.

Prosecutors say Winslow raped three women in incidents dating back years, and also preformed lewd acts involving two others.

There’s been a bit of theme among analysts appearing on the Law&Crime Network so far. They’ve often touched on whether prosecutors packaging the five cases together helps or hurts each individual case. On one hand, the collection of alleged wrongdoing seems to indicate a pattern. The alleged victims tend to be older. Doe 5 is 77. Only Jane Doe 4, who was 17 when she was allegedly raped in 2003, is below the age of 50. On the other hand, perceived weaknesses in a case might, at the very least, fail to buttress the allegations in another. For example, Jane Doe 1 misidentified Winslow in a preliminary hearing last year. During the trial, the defense tried to call her memory in question.

Defense lawyer Ecleynne Mercy construed the cross-examination as a boon for Winslow’s legal team.

“He was able to really stump her on really fundamental parts of her testimony to prove that, hey, what she thought saw, she probably just thought she saw it, and it wasn’t what really actually happened,” she said.

Mercy said she didn’t know why prosecutors even put this case in the trial.

“Personally, I think they should’ve kept it to just Jane Doe number 4,” she said. “But I think what they thought she [5] would add to the case, actually took away from the case. It brought more question marks. It brought more doubt.”

Jane Doe 4 testified Wednesday.

[Screengrab via Law&Crime Network]

More Stories About This Trial

Kellen Winslow II Pleads Guilty Right Before Opening Statements in Retrial

Watch Live: Kellen Winslow II Retrial on Sexual Assault Allegations

Ex-NFL Player Kellen Winslow Will Be Retried on 8 Remaining Criminal Counts

Report: Kellen Winslow Often Masturbated in Front of Teammates, Watched Porn in Meetings

Judge Declares Mistrial on Remaining 8 Charges Against Former NFL TE Kellen Winslow II

Former NFL TE Kellen Winslow II Found Guilty of Rape, But Deliberations Continue on 8 Counts

Juror Note in Kellen Winslow Trial Asks for Explanation as to What ‘Being Under Oath Means’

Daughter of Jane Doe 1 Says Her Mom Denied Testifying in Kellen Winslow Rape Trial

Jane Doe 3 Testifies That She Didn’t See Kellen’s Winslow II’s Face, Only His Tattoos

Things Got Awkward When Defense Told Woman to Look at Former NFL Player Who Allegedly Raped Her

Kellen Winslow II’s Defense Goes After Credibility of Accusers in Rape, Misconduct Case

Flashback: Kellen Winslow II Called Himself a ‘F***ing Soldier’ the Year He Allegedly Raped 17-Year-Old

Verdict Watch: Kellen Winslow II in Rape, Sexual Misconduct Trial (UPDATED)

Opening Statements Set to Begin in Rape Trial of Former NFL First-Round Pick Kellen Winslow II

  1. Mediaite
  2. The Mary Sue
  3. RunwayRiot
  4. Law & Crime
  5. AmboTV