
Lori Vallow appears in court; her dead children, JJ Vallow, on the right, and Tylee Ryan, on the left, appear inset, on April 11, 2023. (Courtroom pool sketch artist; Fremont County Sheriff's Office)
The triple murder trial for Lori Vallow Daybell, 49, a "doomsday cult"-connected mother of two dead children and two dead former husbands continues with a fourth day of testimony in Ada County, Idaho, on Thursday morning.
"There has been a death in the family of one of the prosecutor's lead attorneys," the prosecution said in a statement provided to Law&Crime after proceedings came to a close early on Wednesday afternoon. "The Court and defense have been gracious in allowing the prosecution to adjust to this personal situation."
Vallow and her fifth and current husband, Chad Daybell, 54, stand accused of murder over the 2019 deaths of Joshua "JJ" Vallow, 7, and Tylee Ashlyn Ryan, 17. The children disappeared on different dates in September of that year. Vallow was initially arrested in Hawaii in February 2020 on charges of child desertion. Daybell was arrested later that year after the children's bodies were found buried at his property. The two defendants were indicted for the murder of Vallow's children and Daybell's first wife, Tammy Daybell, 49, in May 2021. Initially being prosecuted as husband-and-wife co-defendants, the couple's cases were recently severed and will be tried separately.
Last week, jury selection wrapped up with 12 jurors and six alternates being chosen from nearly 2,000 Ada County residents who received a summons. The trial is being overseen by Seventh District Judge Steven Boyce, who previously explained to would-be jurors that the complicated case is expected to last as long as eight weeks.
On Wednesday, jurors again heard from the lead Rexburg Police Department detective who worked the case of the missing children – and who was there when their remains were uncovered from shallow graves on Chad Daybell's property. Jurors also heard from Fremont County Sheriff's Deputy Lieutenant Joe Powell, who led the investigation into the murder of Tammy Daybell.
There was also a likely key phone call played in court on Wednesday:
LISTEN: Here is the phone call on the day the children's bodies were found. #ChadDaybell is in his car watching investigators search his yard. Lori happens to call him from jail. She was in jail for not producing kids, Chad gets arrested this day. (played at Chad's prelim) https://t.co/tZU9iLWlDg pic.twitter.com/Rk5gjit4LQ
— Cathy Russon (@cathyrusson) April 12, 2023
Law&Crime correspondent Gigi McKelvey will provide rolling updates as the case progresses Thursday and throughout the trial:
Morning thread: Lori Vallow trial #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori looks to be active with her attorneys this morning. She is talking to both of them and writing things down #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 3:30 P.M. MST – A Recorded Blessing
The blessing was a patriarchal blessing given to any worthy member of the church & given by a stake patriarch to give guidance in your life. Chad gave it. He didn't have the authority to give that blessing. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Here is the transcript of the blessing #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork pic.twitter.com/l2oehWD0Cb
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori has her head down as this is being played. The jury is listening. Some are looking at Lori. You can hear sniffling on the phone. I assume this is Alex. Melanie Gibb said Alex told her he cried like a baby when he got this "blessing" #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
I heard double sniffling so I think Chad and Alex both are crying. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Tammy Daybell was exhumed on December 11, 2019
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 3:10 P.M. MST – A Strange Phone Call
One document has been stipulated and one document comes from Lori's iCloud and doesn't fall under the 404B rule. Thomas says anything coming from AZ falls under 404B. Judge says they'll pick that up if it gets outside of the scope. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Det Duncan was contacted about a call placed to Valley Of The Sun mortuary. The call was places by Chad Daybell inquiring about cremation and shipping costs for Charles's remains #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
He said with the murder of Charles they later learned Tylee and JJ hadn't been seen so they were looking for info on them, attempted murders of Tammy and Brandon. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Chad says his name is "Chad Daybal" and he's calling for estimates about his uncle who just died saying he is helping the family with arrangements. They don't want anything but a cremation and sending him to family in Louisiana. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
When asked for the phone number for callback Chad laughs and says he can't remember and asks her to hold on. He comes back and gives the #. Chad said he passed away in a hospital. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
He is transferred to the mortuary. Chad tells the story again of how he's a nephew helping with arrangements. He said Charles didn't have many relatives (they're taking up 2 rows here, by the way) #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
He is given an amount and she explains other charges on top of that. He's given a ballpark of 2k and says he will call other places and will be in touch. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 2:16 P.M. MST – More on the Death of Charles Vallow
Alex said 2x in the chest from the front. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
She asks if he had been to a scene where CPR had been performed. OBJECTION – Judge says she is laying foundation. Blake says would you see more blood if CPR had been done – he says yes. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Judge Boyce says Mr Thomas can cross examine. Detective says he didn't think CPR had been performed. As far as the self defense claim – Charles had abrasions on his knees but with no furniture it was hard to tell. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Charles was in very good shape. As Charles was being removed they saw a tall baseboard on the flooring and saw a projectile stuck inside the baseboard. It was cut out as evidence #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
He looked at a phone extraction from Charles's phone and Lori's iCloud account "Lori4Style". They found an additional iCloud "Lollitime". Charles Gmail and iCloud was also looked at #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
They viewed emails and texts on his phone. In the weeks and months following his death that he was killed because he was a zombie, there was infidelity (Lori and Chad) #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
This powerpoint is from Charles's phone. Thomas objects and asks when the powerpoint was made. He said this one was made over the last couple of days. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Blake cites law supporting summaries when evidence is voluminous. These messages are available in discovery #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 1:59 P.M. MST – The State Calls Their Next Witness
Detective Duncan is up for the state. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
He was working the day Charles was shot and killed by Alex Cox. He responded to the scene. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
They are bringing in the CAD notes for the case. The originating 911 call was 8:36 and dispatched out at 8:37 AM. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori is watching her attorneys at sidebar occasionally looking at her notepad. The Vallow family is in plain view of her. She doesn't really look over at them. They do look at her. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Judge Boyce will instruct the jury. It will come in. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
The original lead investigator was Nathan Moffat. He was promoted in June 2020 so Detective Duncan was put on as lead detective. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
He saw Charles was laying on his back on a wood planked floor. There were no furniture and mirrors all over the room, which was odd. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
His shirt had been cut away to expose his chest and there was medical equipment on his chest that confirmed death. He saw a gunshot wound on the lower left quadrant of his abdomen. He had blood in the webbing of his left hand #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
There were 2 .45 caliber shell casings on the floor and a projectile near his shoulder which was odd. #LoriVallow @LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 1:31 P.M. MST – The Book of Mormon
Thomas asks Gibb where Lori was when Tammy died and Gibb said she told me Hawaii #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori is listening and watching Gibb as she testifies #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Alex then said the police were evil and they took his guns. Melaniece said her house was broken into. Alex talked about getting married to Zulema. Chad gave Alex a patriarchal blessing and it was touching and emotional for him #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Melaniece was there when Alex said Gibb didn't want to know what happened to JJ. He skirted the issue. Gibb asked Zulema what that meant and Alex told Zulema they couldn't be found. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 1:32 P.M. MST – Back from Lunch
Gibb says September 19th she was told JJ was dark and possessed by an evil spirit. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
He says when she was at Lori's in Sept. she didn't see Tylee. Thomas says she really didn't like you and he says you didn't show kindness to her. Gibb says not true. I am kind. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Thomas – you said Lori told you before Charles's death she wouldn't get the life insurance so monetarily she had no incentive for him to die #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Gibb said Lori knew just prior to Charles being killed the life insurance was changed (Not true) #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Thomas said you told police you had JJ but not anymore. Gibb says yes. He said that wasn't the truth. Gibb says correct. Gibb was in Utah when police called her. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Thomas says you made the recording so you would have audio proof you didn't have JJ and that was self serving? Gibb said it was multi-serving. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
They could communicate through the portal. Lori's was in her closet and she thinks Chad's was on his bed. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
They talk about Korihor. He was an anti-Christ. Eventually he said he was deceived by Satan. Thomas says so you are referring to Lori as an anti-Christ. Gibb says yes. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 11:41 A.M. MST – A Denied Defense Motion
John Thomas is up for cross exam. He asks if she has met with the prosecution over the years and asks the last time she met. She says yes and a few years ago, She didn't meet phyisaclly to prep for the trial. They used Zoom #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Gibb wrote a 7 page outline for the state and gave it to others. Thomas asked if she has a copy and she said she didn't have a copy. She asked but didn't get it. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lindsey Blake asks for a sidebar. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Def attorney Thomas says they object to her testimony and reads the rules for appellate purposes. He says the state received statements from Gibb and she said she met with the state and the state didn't turn them over. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Judge Boyce asks what he wants and asks do you want the jury to forget the entire day's testimony? Judge Boyce says a 7 page outline not supplied would be different but you did get that. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Judge Boyce asks for the jury to be brought back in. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 10:50 A.M. MST – Best Friends No More
It is awkward with Melanie Gibb and Lori. You see them steal glances with each other. Lori shook her head side to side a few times. Lori would whisper some to her attorneys. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 10:26 A.M. MST – Another Phone Call and a Lie
When Gibb contacted law enforcement she told them she did have him prior but Lori had him now. She lied because she felt in a weird and uncomfortable position. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Prosecutor Blake is questioning Melanie. We are about to introduce the recorded conversation between herself, Lori, and Chad from 2019 #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Defense doesn't object to the call being admitted #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Chad says Hello sweet Melanie …. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Here is the secret recording of a phone call between Melanie Gibb, Chad Daybell and Lori Vallow. The jury is currently listening to this. https://t.co/lvkROrW5va https://t.co/CKTEyJYZMz
— Cathy Russon (@cathyrusson) April 13, 2023
Update: 10:14 A.M. MST – Dark, Translated Beings
Lori said she was gonna ask Kay if she could keep him from now on. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
They left for Idaho at the end of August 2019 – Lori, Tylee, JJ, and Alex moved. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Gibb and her then boyfriend has plans to see his son as well. Gibb and her boyfriend David Warwick stayed at Lori's. They didn't see Tylee. Lori said Tylee was at BYUI and moved in the dorms #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori always went to Chad about this and he would share information about the possession to Lori. Lori said JJ's speech was more intelligent, he would say I love Satan, he would climb the refrigerator to the upper cabinets. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
She last saw JJ when Alex took him up to his bedroom. Gibb and David left the next day and they didn't see JJ. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
They did speak occasionally after that visit. Chad would contact her as well. Chad called a few days before Thanksgiving and said Rexburg PD would call and not answer. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori said she told Kay she had cancer and needed JJ to be watched. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Police called Gibb and she didn't respond initially. She says she didn't know what to do. Lori had told Gibb police were dark and after her and they were called "dark translated beings" #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 9:42 A.M. MST – A Happy, Exciting Murder
Gibb says there was happiness and excitement Charles was dead #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 9:32 A.M. MST – First Zombies, Then Murdered
The thought they could cast out "Ned" and believed he left. They would see Charles was alive and it would be another spirit came in. That was Garrett which was cast out then Hiplos came and took over. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
The next casting could have been less of the "group" attending. Lori was present for all castings. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori told Gibb he evolved into a high level dark entity. Lori said Brandon was part of Hitler's regime. Gibb doesn't remember castings for anyone else. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori told Gibb a dark spirit had entered Tylee. This was around April or May. With JJ Gibb was told he was possessed in September 2019. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori was back in AZ when Charles died. Melanie stayed at her house on July 9TH or 10th. After Melanie left Alex spent the night (on the 10th) the night before Charles was murdered. Lori said Alex needed to protect her from Charles. He was going to kill her. #LoriVallow…
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori said she was there for the altercation. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 9:20 A.M. MST – Lori's Ex-Friend Details Her Beliefs
We move on to the light/dark scale. Lori told Gibb people who were light were people who before they came to earth had signed contracts with Jesus and those who were dark signed contracts with Satan. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
People could change from light to dark and dark to light. Melanie said Brandon and Charles never attended these meetings. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori had a dream where Charles was going to Texas and she saw him and JJ in a car accident and Charles died in the dream so Charles would not be coming home in January #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Lori would have revelations about different experiences with Charles. With Chad they thought their spouses would die. That was the plan revealed to them. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Melanie participated in castings in Jan-Feb 2019 after Lori learned Charles was dark. Charles was the 1st one Lori ever called dark. The 1st casting was at Zulema's. Lori, Zulema, Christina, Nicole, Serena, and Melanie were there #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
The original sprit was in a spirit world and stuck between worlds. Sometimes the spirit had moved on – Gibb said it changed a lot. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Update: 9:07 A.M. MST – Melanie Gibb Takes the Stand
Lori is staring Melanie Gibb down. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
She met Chad a year or 2 before she met Lori. She said her and Chad were casual friends. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
She met JJ the same time and place. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
They would see each other daily, several times a week in the beginning until about January 2019. She didn't see her as much as Lori was moving #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
Their communication was inconsistent but often. They took at trip to St George, Utah with several other women for a conference. Chad was there. She saw Chad and Lori interact #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
She talked to Lori about her meeting Chad. Lori said Chad told her they had been married in another time period and she believed it. She already believed in multiple lives #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023
After the conference Melanie contacted Chad periodically – Lori and Chad stayed in touch after the conference. She told Melanie how often they would talk. #LoriVallow@LawCrimeNetwork
— Pretty Lies & Alibis🎙 (@PrettyLiesAlibi) April 13, 2023