Hana St. Juliana's Family Sues Oxford School Over Massacre
Skip to main content

Family of Student Killed in Oxford Massacre Sues School, Alleges Efforts to ‘Cover Up Its Culpability’ for the Shootings

 
Flowers rest at a makeshift memorial outside of Oxford High School on December 1, 2021 in Oxford, Mich. On Tuesday, four students were killed and seven people were injured when a gunman opened fire at the school. The suspect, identified as 15-year-old Ethan Crumbley, has been charged as an adult with terrorism and first-degree murder. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

Flowers rest at a makeshift memorial outside of Oxford High School on Dec. 1, 2021 in Oxford, Mich. Four students were killed and seven people were injured when a gunman opened fire at the school.

Michigan’s Oxford High School knew that accused killer Ethan Crumbley was homicidal and suicidal, but administrators “escalated the danger” by releasing him from a “safe zone” before the massacre, a victim’s family claims in a federal lawsuit.

On Nov. 30, 2021, Crumbley allegedly fatally shot four students and seriously injured seven others. The family of one of the slain high schoolers, Hana St. Juliana, detail the fateful tour hours preceding the shootings in a federal complaint filed in the Eastern District of Michigan.

According to the lawsuit, Crumbley went to school armed with a handgun and bullets that he kept in his backpack. His first hour English teacher told officials that Crumbley was watching a video of a shooting during class, and his second hour math teacher reported Crumbley’s disturbing drawings and jottings on a paper assignment, the family says.

“The thoughts won’t stop,” Crumbley wrote, according the lawsuit. “Help me… blood everywhere… My life is useless… The world is dead.”

Court records contain copies of images allegedly drawn by Ethan Crumbley before he allegedly shot and killed four people at Oxford High School. The image on the left is said by prosecutors to portray a photo of the original drawings; the image on the right depicts how the drawings were allegedly scratched out and modified by Crumbley after a teacher caught him.

Court records contain copies of images allegedly drawn by Ethan Crumbley before he allegedly shot and killed four people at Oxford High School. The image on the left is said by prosecutors to portray a photo of the original drawings; the image on the right depicts how the drawings were allegedly scratched out and modified by Crumbley after a teacher caught him.

The family says that Crumbley’s counselor Shawn Hopkins removed him from class and confiscated the paper with the violent words and images, then brought to a meeting with dean of students, Nicholas Ejak.

Hopkins and Ejak are both named as defendants in the lawsuit.

Both men allegedly concluded that Crumbley had suicidal and homicidal ideation and advised his parents to take their son for immediate mental health counseling. Prosecutors have cited the alleged refusal of his parents—James Crumbley, 45, and Jennifer Crumbley, 43—in their involuntary manslaughter case.

According to the St. Juliana family, Hopkins and Ejak had the authority to keep the younger Crumbley in their office for the rest of the day. Instead, they gave Crumbley a hall pass and returned his unsearched backpack, which contained the alleged murder weapon, the lawsuit says.

A representative for the Oxford Community School District, the lead defendant, did not immediately respond to Law&Crime’s request for comment. The final named defendant, superintendent Ken Weaver, is being sued only in his official capacity.

According to the complaint, the school has previously cited an “adherence to police” defense of its actions, claiming that Crumbley could only be held for a disciplinary matter.

“In truth, the District did know that [Crumbley] was suicidal and possibly homicidal when he was released from the Counselor’s office,” the complaint states. “The District has advanced the ‘adherence to policy’ explanation to cover up its culpability for this tragedy. The truth is that school officials escalated the danger by releasing [Crumbley] from a safe zone with knowledge of [Crumbley]’s propensity to inflict harm upon himself or others.”

The complaint shields Crumbley’s name as John Doe, who is not named as a defendant.

The family members bringing the lawsuit are father Steve St. Juliana and sister Reina St. Juliana, a 16-year-old Oxford student who survived the shooting in a nearby hallway.

They accuse the school and administrators of causing a state-created danger and gross negligence. The lawsuit, said to the be the first of its kind from relatives of a slain Oxford student, seeks unspecified punitive damages under Michigan’s wrongful death statute.

The family also wants a court order requiring the district or Weaver to “publicly retract all statements made in the course of its cover story after the shooting.”

Read the complaint, below:

(Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)

Have a tip we should know? [email protected]

Filed Under:

Follow Law&Crime:

Law&Crime's managing editor Adam Klasfeld has spent more than a decade on the legal beat. Previously a reporter for Courthouse News, he has appeared as a guest on MSNBC, BBC, NPR, PBS, Sky News, and other networks.