A federal judge on Monday granted the “unconditional” release next year of Ronald Reagan’s would-be assassin John Hinckley Jr., some five years after granting his full-time convalescent leave with conditions.
“If he hadn’t tried to kill a president, his release would have been unconditional a long, long, long, long time ago,” Senior U.S. District Judge Paul L. Friedman said.
On March 30, 1981, Hinckley shot and wounded the 40th president outside the Washington Hilton Hotel. Jurors found him not guilty by reason of insanity, finding that he needed treatment instead of punishment. He was 25 years old at the time of the assassination attempt, and he would spend 34 years following the trial committed to St. Elizabeth’s Hospital. He is now 65 years old.
“The most difficult decision was the first one,” Judge Friedman said, referring to the initial decision to release Hinckley in “incremental steps.”
“Once I opened that door a crack, this day would come,” Friedman added. “Maybe others wouldn’t open the door a crack. I don’t know, but I followed the law. I followed the facts. I followed the science.”
In addition to Reagan, Hinckley shot Presidential Press Secretary James Brady, Secret Service Agent Timothy McCarthy, and Metropolitan Police Officer Thomas Delahanty. Identifying with the main character of the film Taxi Driver, Hinckley developed an obsession with actress Jodie Foster, who was 12 years old in that film. The film’s protagonist Travis Bickle unsuccessfully plots to assassinate a presidential candidate to try to win the affections of Foster’s character.
On the day of the attack, Hinckley wrote her a letter saying that he would kill the president to impress her. He was diagnosed as having major depression and a psychotic disorder.
Judge Friedman issued his ruling during evidentiary proceedings on Monday.
Hinckley’s attorney Barry Levine, from the firm Blank Rome, said that his client’s mother died roughly two months ago.
“I would like to ask the court’s indulgence to make a comment that I think is appropriate,” Levine said in court. “That is to say that, Mr. Hinckley wants to express apologies, and his apologies are heartfelt and one of profound regret.”
The lawyer said that Hinckley extends those apologies to the Reagan family, as well as the families of Brady and McCarthy.
Separately apologizing on his client’s behalf to Ms. Foster, Levine added: “He apologies to the American people.”
Adding that asking for forgiveness may be “too much,” Levine added he hoped for their understanding.
“He was ravaged by mental illness at the time,” Levine noted. “It was that mental illness that led to his acquittal.”
Assistant U.S. Attorney Kacie McCoy Weston noted that Hinckley has been a unique patient of St. Elizabeth’s Hospital, in that no other one to her knowledge has attempted to assassinate a U.S. president.
A doctor working for Washington’s Department of Behavioral Health had recommended Weston’s unconditional release, but Weston added that another government expert, Dr. Mitchell Hugonnet, recommended prolonging Hinckley’s observation in light of his mother’s death and the departure of his therapist.
“We can speculate as to how Mr. Hinckley will adapt to these changes, but why should we?” Weston asked.
She argued this was especially prudent in light of Hinckley’s psychological predisposition.
“Mr. Hinckley does have a history of turning inward and toward isolation,” she said.
Despite agreeing that the court record would support a finding of conditional release, prosecutors recommend a nine-month stay for further observation.
“At this point, the ball is in Mr. Hinckley’s hands,” Weston said.
Judge Friedman appeared skeptical of the need for delay: “This nine months is not a magic number,” the judge said.
The prosecutor agreed that was true. The judge nonetheless agreed to make the unconditional release effective June 2020.
Judge Friedman said he would issue a written order later this week.
(Photo by Hulton Archive/Getty Images)
Have a tip we should know? [email protected]