FILE – Bill Essayli, acting U.S. Attorney for the Central District of California, speaks with reporters during a news conference at the Department of Justice, Nov. 19, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein, file).
A federal judge on Monday refused to pause his order ousting the Trump administration's top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles after ruling that Bill Essayli was unlawfully serving as a "de facto" U.S. attorney.
In a 12-page order, Senior U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright rejected the government's motion to stay his Oct. 27 decision pending appeal, concluding the administration failed to show it would suffer irreparable harm and had a "low likelihood of success on the merits."
Seabright, a George W. Bush appointee from the District of Hawaii, was assigned the case after the judges sitting in the Central District of California recused themselves due to the institutional relationship between the U.S. attorney's office and the bench.
The Oct. 27 ruling bars Essayli from participating in or supervising the prosecutions of Jaime Hector Ramirez and Tu Anh Tran, who face firearm and stolen-property charges, respectively. The October order disqualifying Essayli is set to take effect Nov. 23, "subject to any further orders of this court or an appellate court."
Seabright ruled in October 2025 that Essayli could not lawfully serve as acting U.S. attorney without Senate approval, but let him stay on under the newly created title of First Assistant U.S. Attorney (FAUSA).
But when the 9th Circuit on Aug. 17 rejected a similar arrangement for Nevada's Sigal Chattah, the defendants challenging Essayli's "FAUSA" role asked Seabright to reconsider his decision.
According to Seabright, the government conceded it would "suffer no injury from the immediate, practical effect" of keeping Essayli off the two cases. Instead, the DOJ asserted that the judge's ruling intruded on the executive branch's authority over prosecutions.
Seabright was not persuaded. From the ruling:
To the extent the government argues that [the October ruling] encroaches upon Executive branch functions by "dictating" who can prosecute Defendants' cases, it misconstrues the court's ruling. [That ruling] dictates no such thing. Instead, it merely applies the law.
Seabright called the government's separation-of-powers arguments "vague and conclusory," noting that the DOJ failed to identify "any specific harm it is likely to suffer" when his order takes effect.
The judge also rejected the DOJ's claim that his order would "disrupt federal law enforcement," writing: "Indeed, it is the government's requested stay that may further delay the prosecution at issue."
He further denied the DOJ's claim that the order "potentially affects 5,000 cases in the largest district in the country," calling it a "bald assertion, absent any support or explanation" that was raised for the first time in the government's latest reply memorandum.
Additionally, Seabright took issue with how the government quoted a 2023 decision from the 9th Circuit as holding that courts "do not dictate to the Executive branch who will serve as its prosecutors."
As Seabright points out, the full passage from the 9th Circuit begins with the qualifier "Absent a violation of . . . the Constitution, a federal statute, or a procedural rule," and ends by stating that courts do not dictate who serves as prosecutors "unless compelled by the law to do so."
"Thus, despite the expansive and misleading nature of the government's excerpted language, [the 9th Circuit's ruling] neither holds nor suggests that a court offends separation of powers by disqualifying an Executive official who is unlawfully serving," the order states.
The government has also asked the Supreme Court to review the 9th Circuit's ruling, but Seabright refused to hold his order until the justices make a decision. A stay tied to that petition would be indefinite, he wrote, citing a prior 9th Circuit ruling warning that such a stay could last "perhaps for years."
The Supreme Court has yet to decide whether it will take up the case.