Left: Kennedy Schroer. Insets top to bottom: Crystina Schroer, Joseph Schroer (Rose Hill Police Department). Background: Home in Rose Hill, Kansas, where Kennedy was allegedly killed (Google Maps).
A Kansas mom is headed to prison for nearly two decades after she stuffed her adopted 6-year-old daughter in a box and left her inside while she suffocated to death.
Crystina Elizabeth Schroer, 50, on Monday was sentenced to more than 17 years in prison for the death of Kennedy Schroer, whose body was discovered buried at the family's home in September 2024 in Rose Hill, a town of 4,000 people southeast of Wichita. Schroer in August pleaded no contest to second-degree murder, child abuse, making false information and welfare fraud. She was originally facing a first-degree murder charge.
Schroer's husband, Joseph Schroer, is slated to be sentenced on child endangerment charges on Dec. 3.
Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.
A 44-page probable cause arrest affidavit details the horrific death Kennedy suffered at the hands of her mother in late 2020. The investigation began in September 2024 when Rose Hill police officers responded to a home after a suicide attempt by Crystina Schroer. When cops arrived, she told them "her life was over and that no one was going to look at her the same."
She went on to say that one night in November or December of 2020 her kids got into a fight and she was trying to separate them. She went outside and asked one of her kids where was Kennedy. The girl was looking at a box that had a crib and blankets on top of it. Crystina Schroer claimed she took the blankets and cradle off the box and opened it to find Kennedy in the box, "unconscious and without a pulse."
The mother tried to complete CPR on Kennedy but to no avail, and she realized the girl was dead. She then proceeded to drive around with the girl's body, and eventually decided to bury her in a 23-inch grave in the backyard of her home. She said it was one of the kids who put her in the box.
Detectives interviewed the child, but they couldn't get her to speak and they left the room. Some time later, Joseph Schroer came out and asked to go to the bathroom, and told investigators they should review the video from the room as he was able to get the girl to open up.
The girl said the incident occurred when her dad was at work. She said her mother would force the kids to enter a storage container box if they moved during the night. According to the affidavit, she said her mom forced Kennedy into the box. The girl had to listen for her sister to make any movements or noises. Kennedy made a noise.
"[The sister] believed her mom heard that and came back into the room, asking 'is she still making noises?'" the affidavit said.
The defendant then placed the blankets and crib on top of the box before leaving the room.
"When mom came back into the room, [the sister] was bawling, and mom asked why and she stated she Kennedy thought was dead, because she wasn't making any noise," detectives wrote.
She opened the box and Kennedy fell out. The girl was "blue." The sister never saw Kennedy again. Detectives wrote that Crystina Schroer told her husband and other family members that the state took back custody of the girl because she was unable to live in a foster home because of behavior issues.
As Law&Crime previously reported, cops began searching the Schroer home in the 1400 block of North Meeker Court after Crystina Schroer's suicide attempt.
Cops went to the home early the next day and began their search.
They encountered some hurdles right away. The vegetation was so overgrown that they had to take a bush whacker to clear the way so cadaver dogs could search the area. Once completed, the dogs alerted investigators to some areas of interest.
Hours into the forensic dig, cops uncovered the remains of young girl inside a trash bag in a makeshift grave about 2 feet deep. A couple weeks later a DNA test positively identified the body as Kennedy.
Detectives learned Kennedy was born Natalie Garcia on July 14, 2014, a press release said. Her birth parents relinquished their rights to the state and she was put up for adoption. The Schroers adopted her in November 2018 and changed her name. Police believe she was suffocated to death in late 2020. Her death was ruled a homicide.
"She was a beautiful child, with an infectious smile," cops said.
Since the discovery of the body, police have spent some 2,000 hours building a case against the Schroers, working with local, state and federal law enforcement, including the FBI, Internal Revenue Service and Wichita's Exploited and Missing Children's Unit.
"This case was built through the development of timelines spanning more than four years, which is the primary reason for the length of the investigation," cops wrote.
Investigators also learned the suspect parents had been receiving some $23,000 in Medicaid payments after Kennedy's death. The parents had three biological children and two adopted kids. The surviving children all have been placed in custody of the state since the discovery of Kennedy's body.