President Donald Trump delivers the Memorial Day Address at the 157th National Memorial Day Observance at Arlington National Cemetery, Monday, May 26, 2025, in Arlington, Va., as Vice President JD Vance and Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, right, look on (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson).

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) is imploring a federal judge to reject the Trump administration's latest batch of arguments in favor of keeping secret the government's internal decision-making and justifications for fatal attacks on boats in the Caribbean.

In a nine-page memorandum of law filed on Friday, the group said the latest series of submissions by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) "reinforce what was already apparent." Namely, the ACLU says "the presidential communications privilege does not apply" to the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) memo on the boat strikes.

In August 2025, operating on a presidential directive authorizing military force against "foreign criminal groups," the Department of Defense (DOD) began attacking boats it claimed were trafficking drugs into the country. Some 234 people have been killed in those attacks while the government has not provided evidence conclusively proving its claims, according to the underlying lawsuit.

Litigation began in December 2025 after the ACLU and others filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request. In denying the request, and thus withholding the OLC memo in full, the DOD cited exemptions to the nation's premier government transparency law.

During motions practice, the parties considered two exemptions. In theory, these concessions would have allowed for a limited release of the OLC memo with redactions after the document was reviewed by U.S. District Judge Paul Engelmayer, a Barack Obama appointee.

The government, however, said one of those exemptions meant it could still withhold the OLC memo in full by citing the presidential communications privilege — a form of executive privilege.

Now, the ACLU says several admissions by the Trump administration itself have doomed the government's bid for continued secrecy.

"Defendants now concede that multiple subordinate officials reviewed the memo solely to 'inform their views' about carrying out executive branch policy or to advise other subordinate officials in doing so," the group's filing reads. "As this Court and others have held, such 'downstream dissemination' of a presidential advice document for non-advisory purposes is 'inconsistent with the privilege's narrow parameters' and thus eviscerates it."

In a late October ruling, Engelmayer addressed the "downstream dissemination" concept while explaining to the DOJ how some earlier arguments would not apply to the claimed privilege.

The judge, in "emphasizing the privilege's narrow contours," said that "even wide downstream dissemination within the Executive Branch of a President's privileged presidential communications could not effect a waiver would be inconsistent with the privilege's narrow parameters[.]"

In other words, the judge said the privilege could be waived if the claimed information was widely disseminated within the executive branch. The ACLU says that is exactly what happened with the OLC memo in question.

Moreover, the storied civil liberties group says the memo has been shared far beyond the confines of the nation's war-planning agency.

"Several DOJ attorneys reviewed the OLC memo solely in their capacities as defense counsel in litigation concerning the U.S. government's wrongful killing of two Trinidadian men in an October 2025 boat strike," the group's filing continues. "These DOJ lawyers are well beyond the President's inner circle, and their review was not in service of presidential decision-making."

The ACLU memo elaborates here:

It was thus incompatible with "the privilege's narrow contours." And any suggestion that their access to the memo was necessary to defend the government in litigation is just as illogical as Defendants' claim, twice rejected by this Court, that military personnel needed to see the memo to understand the scope of their authority to initiate or conduct a boat strike.

The filing also offers a tertiary reason for the court to reject the government's secrecy arguments.

"Defendants presented the memo to numerous members of Congress after they demanded access to the legal basis and governing parameters of the boat strikes campaign," the filing goes on. "After freely offering up the memo to members of a 'rival political branch,'—including the ranking members of key oversight committees—Defendants cannot now credibly claim that they treat the memo as containing closely held advice that the President's advisors would be 'unwilling to express except privately.'"

The ACLU notes that the Trump administration has protested that "holding the privilege inapplicable would yield intolerable non-secrecy-preserving outcomes." But the group also notes that the government "affirmatively abrogated other executive privileges that ordinarily protect similar documents from disclosure."

"[T]he presidential communications privilege is not a broad, fail-safe privilege that the government may rely upon simply because all other privileges have been lost," the filing summarizes. "It cannot—and need not—be conscripted into serving the same purposes as distinct executive privileges that, due to Defendants' choice to expressly adopt the memo as working law, no longer shield it from public release. The Court should deny Defendants' motion for summary judgment."