Inset left: Trevor McEuen (Texas Department of Public Safety). Right: Aaron Martinez (Obituary). Background: The stretch of rural road where McEuen killed his neighbor in Forney, Texas, in May 2023 (Google Maps).
A Texas man will spend the rest of his life behind bars for killing his neighbor in a sustained hail of gunfire – a shooting he admitted but claimed was self-defense.
On Thursday, Trevor Rhea McEuen, 33, was convicted on one count of capital murder by a jury of his peers in Kaufman County.
Minutes later, 422nd District Court Judge Shelton Gibbs IV sentenced the defendant to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Prosecutors did not seek the death penalty, necessitating the sentence meted out to McEuen under Lone Star State law.
The underlying incident occurred on May 1, 2023, on Neal Road in Forney – a small town located roughly 25 miles due east of Dallas.
That day, Aaron Martinez, 35, died after being shot 32 times by McEuen, following several instances of harassment.
Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.
The man's factual culpability was not challenged.
Rather, McEuen claimed his actions were in self-defense.
"Nobody is saying he didn't shoot him," the defendant's attorney, Abigail Spain, told jurors on Thursday, according to a courtroom report by Fort Worth-based NBC affiliate KXAS. "He shot him. He was justified. He was scared. He used deadly force because he thought it was going to be used against him."
The jury rejected those arguments.
After four hours of deliberation following a four-day trial, the jury returned a guilty verdict.
"Justice was served in this case thanks to the tireless efforts of our investigators, the District Attorney's Office, and all the agencies that assisted throughout this investigation," Kaufman County Sheriff Bryan Beavers said in a press release announcing the verdict and sentencing. "Our thoughts remain with the Martinez family, and we hope this verdict brings them some measure of peace."
During the trial, jurors learned that McEuen used a semi-automatic rifle to repeatedly shoot Martinez following an altercation near the victim's property — one of those shots struck Martinez's forehead.
"This was not just about some sort of road rage incident or some kind of family drama," Assistant District Attorney Robyn Beckham said, in comments reported by Dallas-based Fox affiliate KDFW. "This was something more than that. The 32 gunshot wounds, that is what the jury needed to see."
In court, prosecutors termed the murder an "act of hatred."
Details of neighborly issues were revealed in court documents obtained by Tyler-based ABC and Telemundo affiliate KLTV.
An affidavit claims Martinez hired several men to work on his home, putting up a fence "to avoid the problems" with McEuen. Problems allegedly included the eventual killer climbing on his roof and shouting to provoke Martinez's family, described as "out of the blue yelling at everyone on Aaron's property as if he was angry."
McEuen would also frequently use derogatory language and once accused Martinez of being "crazy," one document alleged.
On the day of the shooting, Martinez left at around 11 a.m. to get more construction supplies and pick up lunch for the workers. Minutes later, gunshots rang out. Deputies found the victim slumped over in his truck – the engine still on and idling in the middle of the street.
"They knew it was Trevor," law enforcement wrote in one of the court documents, referring to the workers at the victim's home.
Following a SWAT standoff, the defendant was taken into custody and admitted to killing his neighbor. He quickly made $2 million bail but missed a court date on May 5, 2023, after removing his ankle monitor.
After a monthlong manhunt and another SWAT standoff, McEuen was taken back into custody, according to a "most wanted fugitive" posting by the Texas Department of Public Safety.
The slain man is remembered fondly in his obituary:
He Enjoyed Horse Riding, going to the Gun Range, all outdoor activities, traveling, family gatherings, listening to Banda music, playing with his children, niece and nephews and spending time in his Ranch with his horses. Aaron worked at The Omni Hotel and recently owned his business, JVC Electric.His biggest accomplishments were owning his own business, becoming a U.S. Citizen, building his dream ranch, giving back to the community but most of all his dear Children.
"I'm just, you know, very emotional about what happened just now. But I'm good," the victim's father told assembled local media in North Texas after the verdict. "The main thing is, this guy, he stays forever, and he will cause no more damage to nobody, because he was a dangerous man."