
Inset left: William Bryan Morgan (Eighth Judicial Circuit Solicitor's Office). Inset right: Caleb Donnelly (Obituary). Background: The residence where Morgan shot and killed Donnelly in Greenwood County, S.C. (Google Maps).
A South Carolina man will spend three decades behind bars for "hunting down" his stepson and killing him.
William Bryan Morgan, 36, was convicted earlier this week on one count of murder over the death of 29-year-old Caleb Donnelly, according to a press release issued by the Eighth Judicial Circuit Solicitor's Office.
In quick fashion, the defendant was sentenced by Circuit Judge Thomas William McGee III to 30 years in prison, which "must be served day for day with no possibility of parole," prosecutors said.
The investigation dates back to June 2021.
The first recorded sign of trouble occurred when Greenwood County Sheriff's Office deputies were called to a domestic dispute between Morgan and Donnelly that occurred at a party at another residence.
In an attempt to de-escalate tensions, deputies took Donnelly to his "room" in a converted outbuilding behind Morgan's house.
But deputies were back to try to calm things down between the two men soon enough — in response to Donnelly damaging property inside Morgan's residence, according to prosecutors.
By then, however, Morgan took the law into his own hands.
"While deputies were on scene speaking with Donnelly's mother, Morgan returned to the residence, retrieved a .357 Magnum revolver, and went looking for Donnelly," the press release reads.
While the defendant was out searching for his stepson, deputies told the victim's mother that they likely had enough evidence to hold Donnelly over the weekend due to the property damage. This respite, law enforcement assured the woman, would allow the family to try to deal with the younger man's purported mental health issues.
But the respite never came.
"Not long after deputies left from Morgan's residence, they were called a third time when Donnelly's body was discovered in his small outbuilding," the prosecutor's press release goes on.
By then, the defendant had fled the scene of the crime, according to law enforcement. He was arrested two days later as he emerged from the woods near his property, authorities said.
"During an interview, Morgan admitted to killing Donnelly by shooting his stepson several times," the press release goes on. "Morgan admitted he took matters into his own hands and told investigators he fired the last shot into Donnelly's neck to put Donnelly 'out of his misery.'"
While the case took years to resolve, jurors only deliberated for two hours following an eight-day trial before returning a guilty verdict.
"William Morgan hunted down and killed a family member simply because he had grown weary of dealing with the symptoms of Caleb's mental illness," Eighth Circuit Solicitor David M. Stumbo said in a statement following the sentencing. "Caleb deserved compassion, not bloodshed and death, from family that he trusted. Our office will continue to stand up for vulnerable victims and hold those who harm them accountable."
The victim was remembered fondly in his obituary.
"Caleb was a talented tattoo artist and enjoyed writing," the eulogy reads. "He loved his family dearly and especially loved being a father and uncle."
Comments