Inset (left): Benjamin Carpenter (Milwaukee County Sheriff's Office). Inset (right): Erica Carpenter (Church & Chapel Family-Owned Funeral Service). Background: The home in West Allis, Wis., where Erica Carpenter was fatally injured (Google Maps).

A Wisconsin man who allegedly tried to cover up the killing of his wife has been arrested following a two-year investigation.

Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was taken into custody on Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in connection with the death of his wife, 40-year-old Erica Carpenter. According to a criminal complaint reviewed by Law&Crime, police responded to the Carpenters' home in West Allis, Wisconsin, on the night of Oct. 13, 2024, after receiving a call about a woman who "fell and was bleeding from the head." Police said Benjamin Carpenter was performing CPR on his wife, whose face was already "very blue."

Police spoke with Benjamin Carpenter at the scene, and he explained that his wife had not been feeling well that day and took several naps. That night, Benjamin and Erica Carpenter were "doing laundry together" when she "collapsed," he said. Benjamin Carpenter told police that she fell so hard that it was "loud enough to wake their son who was sleeping upstairs." He also told police that she hit her head "mildly hard" on the carpeted floor.

Instead of calling for help, Benjamin Carpenter allegedly carried his unconscious wife up the stairs. According to the complaint, Benjamin Carpenter told police that he "slipped" on the steps and "they both fell down the stairs." He claimed that Erica Carpenter hit her head on the cinder block wall on the way down.

Erica Carpenter was transported to the hospital and was pronounced dead at 5:14 a.m. on Oct. 14, 2024.

When questioned by police about the state of their marriage, Benjamin Carpenter said, "It's (short pause) good." He consented to having all three of his phones searched by police and provided passcodes for all of them. When asked if he deleted anything from them in the past 24 hours, Benjamin Carpenter denied that he did.

Police said that after news of Erica Carpenter's death reached the couple's social circles, an individual approached authorities on Oct. 22, 2024. The witness informed them that a woman, identified with the initials "A.M.V.," said she had been having an affair with Benjamin Carpenter and believed that he was in the process of divorcing his wife. A.M.V. reportedly told the witness that Benjamin Carpenter had promised to ask Erica Carpenter for a divorce the same weekend she died.

The witness also told police that they learned Benjamin Carpenter spent the night at A.M.V.'s house days after his wife's death and said he wanted to introduce A.M.V. to his son on Oct. 21, 2024.

About a month after Erica Carpenter's death, a pub-crawl benefit was held in her honor. Police said surveillance footage showed Benjamin Carpenter and A.M.V. "portraying themselves as a couple."

Police spoke with another witness, who said they had done mixed martial arts with Benjamin Carpenter and had known him since high school. This witness told police that Benjamin Carpenter admitted that he had been having an affair with A.M.V. and had been in the process of divorcing Erica Carpenter after she found out about the affair.

According to the complaint, the witness said "several bar patrons" expressed their surprise that Benjamin Carpenter had brought "a new girlfriend" to the bar so soon after his wife's death. The same witness said "people were upset" that A.M.V. had been present at the pub-crawl benefit.

More from Law&Crime: Husband killed wife, then enlisted niece to trick authorities into believing she was alive and living overseas: Cops

When police interviewed Benjamin Carpenter in December 2024, they learned that he had collected "$220,000 or $230,000" of Erica Carpenter's life insurance policy. There was also a joint policy worth $350,000 that had not yet been paid out. During the interview, Benjamin Carpenter allegedly admitted to police that he had been having an affair with A.M.V. in the months leading up to Erica Carpenter's death. He reportedly said that A.M.V. "did not want to date him until he got a divorce" and "pushed him away."

Police said they spoke with several friends of the Carpenters who were seemingly unaware of any marital issues between the couple, which "contradicted" Benjamin Carpenter's description of his marriage.

An autopsy revealed that Erica Carpenter had hydrocodone in her system but had not been prescribed the drug, police said. Its presence "cannot be ruled out" as a possible contributor to her death. Erica Carpenter's cause of death was listed as undetermined, but she had blunt force injuries to the neck and petechial hemorrhaging, both signs of a possible "asphyxia death."

The medical examiner spoke to Benjamin Carpenter over the phone to ask about how he was holding his wife while they fell down the stairs. According to the complaint, the medical examiner said Benjamin Carpenter's account of events "would not explain why Erica Carpenter's heart stopped beating."

Police said that in May 2025, they were called again to Benjamin Carpenter's West Allis home after A.M.V., who was living there at the time, said Benjamin Carpenter "placed his hand around her neck and strangled her." Police said A.M.V. told the Uber driver who picked her up that if she "were to die, it was him who did it," then showed the driver Benjamin Carpenter's contact card in her phone.

In June 2025, police reviewed the evidence from the search warrant on Benjamin Carpenter's phones. According to the complaint, he searched Google for "Watching someone you love die" on Sept. 19, 2024, and "can I crush pills and take them in water" on Oct. 13, 2024. Another search on Nov. 6, 2024, reportedly led to a Facebook image that read, "The hardest thing in the world is watching someone you love slowly die right in front of you." Police also wrote in the complaint that the search warrant found that Benjamin Carpenter had deleted text messages, despite his denial that he did so.

Another review of the phone evidence indicated that Erica Carpenter reportedly questioned her husband about putting something in her drinking water. On Sept. 18, 2024, she texted, "And what the f— have you been doing to my water the past few days?!?!?" She later texted, "There's been powdery s— in it at least twice now." He texted back that he was putting "liquid IV" in it for himself and told her it was his water.

Police spoke to the Carpenters' son in October 2025. He told police that on the night of his mother's fatal fall, he heard a "thud" after hearing a "scream." The son told police that four weeks after his mother died, his father removed photos of Erica Carpenter from the home. He confirmed that A.M.V. moved into the home two or three months after his mother's death.

Benjamin Carpenter is in custody at the Milwaukee County Jail, where he is being held without bond. He was scheduled to make his initial appearance in court on Wednesday.